Table 8: Rank of the five best mapping functions for Egypt, based on corresponding mean differences, rms and percent error with respect to those computed using the ray trace model.
a) 30˚ elevation angle |
15˚ elevation angle |
MF |
Mean difference |
rms |
Percent error |
rank |
MF |
Mean difference |
rms |
Percent error |
rank |
SA |
22.19 |
6.48 |
8.24 |
1 |
CH |
43.49 |
12.69 |
8.39 |
1 |
MO |
22.45 |
6.56 |
8.34 |
2 |
MO |
43.56 |
12.71 |
8.40 |
2 |
CH |
22.47 |
6.56 |
8.35 |
3 |
IF |
44.95 |
13.12 |
8.67 |
3 |
IF |
22.59 |
6.60 |
8.39 |
4 |
HE |
44.95 |
13.12 |
8.67 |
4 |
HE |
22.60 |
6.60 |
8.40 |
5 |
UNB |
45.07 |
13.15 |
8.70 |
5 |
b) 10˚ elevation angle |
9˚ elevation angle |
MF |
Mean difference |
rms |
Percent error |
rank |
MF |
Mean difference |
rms |
Percent error |
rank |
SA |
57.64 |
16.83 |
7.50 |
1 |
SA |
62.20 |
18.16 |
7.31 |
1 |
CH |
64.93 |
18.93 |
8.45 |
2 |
CH |
72.09 |
21.01 |
8.46 |
2 |
MO |
65.38 |
19.06 |
8.51 |
3 |
MO |
72.80 |
21.22 |
8.55 |
3 |
IF |
69.94 |
20.39 |
9.10 |
4 |
IF |
78.93 |
23.00 |
9.27 |
4 |
HE |
70.00 |
20.42 |
9.11 |
5 |
HE |
79.03 |
23.05 |
9.28 |
5 |
c) 7˚ elevation angle |
5˚ elevation angle |
MF |
Mean difference |
rms |
Percent error |
rank |
MF |
Mean difference |
rms |
Percent error |
rank |
SA |
72.18 |
21.08 |
6.65 |
1 |
SA |
76.52 |
22.47 |
5.13 |
1 |
CH |
92.51 |
26.94 |
8.52 |
2 |
CH |
128.85 |
37.44 |
8.63 |
2 |
MO |
94.49 |
27.50 |
8.71 |
3 |
MO |
136.01 |
39.51 |
9.11 |
3 |
IF |
106.57 |
31.04 |
9.82 |
4 |
HE |
165.22 |
48.13 |
10.97 |
4 |
HE |
106.92 |
31.06 |
9.85 |
5 |
IF |
163.81 |
47.67 |
11.07 |
5 |