Based on the experimental results of cold-formed thin-walled steel lipped channel sections, the uncertainty of calculating mode of load-carrying capacity using effective width method considering distortional buckling for different material types cold-formed steel compressed members was researched, and the uncertainties of material strength and geometric characteristics of the typical sections were statistically analyzed.
According to the recommended resistance of partial coefficient in the draft of Technical code of cold-formed steel structures (GB50018-), the reliability indexes of cold-formed thin-walled steel lipped channel sections under compression were investigated using the improved first-order second-moment method considering different possible external loading combinations.
The analyzed results show that, using the recommended resistance partial coefficient in the code draft, the reliability indexes of the compressed members with width-thickness ratio within the limitation of code draft can well met the target reliability index. The suitability of the corresponding calculating modes of load-carrying capacity considering distortional buckling was established.
Open Peer Review Details | |||
---|---|---|---|
Manuscript submitted on 07-08-2017 |
Original Manuscript | Design Reliability Analysis of Cold-Formed Thin-Walled Steel Members with Lipped Channel Sections Considering Distortional Buckling |
Cold-formed lipped channel sections have been widely used in residential and commercial construction recently. Distortional buckling occurs for cold-formed thin-walled lipped channel sections under compressed load because of large width-to-thickness ratio of the flanges and weak torsional restraint of lip to flange. The direct strength method has been put forward to estimate the distortional buckling strength of lipped channel sections based on the test and theoretical analysis [1B.W. Schafer, "Local, distortional, and Euler buckling of thin-walled columns", J. Struc. Eng., vol. 128, no. 3, pp. 289-299.
[http://dx.doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9445(2002)128:3(289)] -5Y.B. Kwon, B.S. Kim, and G.J. Hancock, "Compression tests of high strength cold-formed steel channels with buckling interaction", J. Construct. Steel Res., vol. 65, no. 2, pp. 278-289.
[http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jcsr.2008.07.005] ]. The distortional buckling mechanical behavior and design method were studied for lipped channel sections fabricated with LG550, S350, S280 steel plates [6L. Yuanqi, W. Shukun, S. Zuyan, and Y. Xingyou, "Experimental study and load-carrying capacity analysis of high-strength cold-formed thin-walled steel channel column under axial compression", J. Build. Struc., vol. 31, no. 11, pp. 17-25.-10S. Yanyong, Experimental investigation on load-carrying capacities of eccentrically-compressed members and self-drilling screw shear connections of cold-formed thin-walled steel structures, M.S. Thesis, Tongji University: Shanghai, China, 2008]. Then recommend design method for distortional buckling strength was given [11JGJ227-2011, Technical specification for low-rise cold-formed thin-walled steel buildings, China Architecture and Building Press: Beijing, .]. The reliability analysis of the recommend method show that the design method in Chinese code considering distortional buckling is suitable for lipped channel sections fabricated with LG550 [12L. Yuanqi, S. Zuyan, and W. Lei, "Design reliability analysis of high-strength cold-formed thin-walled steel members with lipped channel sections", J. Build. Struc., vol. 31, no. 11, pp. 36-44.], S350 [13L. Yuanqi, X. Hu, and S. Zuyan, "Design reliability analysis of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with S350 hard-rolled steel sheets", Prog. Steel Build. Struc., vol. 149, no. 6, pp. 21-29.], S280 [14L. Yuanqi, X. Hu, and S. Zuyan, "Design reliability analysis of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with S280 hard-rolled steel sheets", J. Tongji Uni. (Natural Sci.), vol. 40, no. 8, pp. 1154-1162.] steel plates if the suitable resistance partial coefficient is used.
To simplify the calculated method of distortional buckling load-carrying capacities for lipped channel sections, a study [15Y. Xingyou, L. Yuanqi, and S. Zuyan, "Nonlinear distortional-buckling strength estimation of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with lipped channel section", J. Cent. South Uni. (Sci. and Tech.), vol. 46, no. 8, pp. 3067-3074., 16Y. Xingyou, and L. Yuanqi, "Distortional buckling strength of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with lipped channel section", Eng. Mech., vol. 319, no. 9, pp. 174-181.] has given the improved width method considering the distortional buckling using energy method based on the test results. The design reliability of the cold-formed thin-walled steel members with lipped channel sections considering distortional buckling for different material type cold-formed steel compressed members was researched using the improved first-order second-moment method based on the experimental results in this paper.
The detailed distortional buckling experiments for lipped channel sections fabricated with LG550, S350, S280 steel plates can be found in reference [6L. Yuanqi, W. Shukun, S. Zuyan, and Y. Xingyou, "Experimental study and load-carrying capacity analysis of high-strength cold-formed thin-walled steel channel column under axial compression", J. Build. Struc., vol. 31, no. 11, pp. 17-25.-10S. Yanyong, Experimental investigation on load-carrying capacities of eccentrically-compressed members and self-drilling screw shear connections of cold-formed thin-walled steel structures, M.S. Thesis, Tongji University: Shanghai, China, 2008]. These experiments include axially compressed members and eccentrically compressed members for lipped channel sections fabricated with LG550, S350, S280 steel plates. The eccentrical experiments include bending about strong axial, bending about weak axial (eccentric to web), and bending about weak axial (eccentric to web).The overall view of compressed columns tests arrangements is shown in Fig. (1). The columns were fixed supported for axially compressed stud columns. The other column specimens were used to simulate the hinged-hinged support using two knife hinges at every end.
Fig. (1) Overall view of compressed columns tests setup. |
The typical buckling mode for LG550 axially compressed members is shown in Fig. (2). Distortional buckling and local buckling occurred for stud columns, medium columns, and columns bending about strong axial. Distortional buckling and overall flexural buckling occurred for long members. The buckling mode for S350 and S280 axially compressed members was observed to be same to the LG550 members.
Fig. (2) Typical buckling mode for axially compressed columns. |
The typical buckling mode for LG550 eccentrically compressed members is shown in Fig. (3). Distortional buckling took place for the specimens bending about weak axial and load was eccentric to lip (Fig. 3a) and bending about strong axial (Fig. 3b). With the increase of the slenderness ratio, the interaction among distortional buckling and overall buckling occurred for the specimens bending about weak axial and load was eccentric to the lip (Fig. 3c) and bending about strong axial (Fig. 3d).The interaction among local buckling and overall buckling occurred for the specimens bending about weak axial and load was eccentric to web (Fig. 3e). The buckling mode for S350 and S280 eccentrically compressed members were observed to be same to the LG550 members.
Fig. (3) Typical buckling mode for eccentrically compressed columns. |
The tested ultimate tested compressive load strength and buckling mode for all specimens can be found in reference [6L. Yuanqi, W. Shukun, S. Zuyan, and Y. Xingyou, "Experimental study and load-carrying capacity analysis of high-strength cold-formed thin-walled steel channel column under axial compression", J. Build. Struc., vol. 31, no. 11, pp. 17-25.-10S. Yanyong, Experimental investigation on load-carrying capacities of eccentrically-compressed members and self-drilling screw shear connections of cold-formed thin-walled steel structures, M.S. Thesis, Tongji University: Shanghai, China, 2008].
Distortional buckling occurs for cold-formed thin-walled lipped channel sections under compressed load because of large width-to-thickness ratio of the flanges and weak torsional restraint of lip to flange. A study [17Y. Xingyou, Distortional buckling behavior and design method of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with opening section, Report, Tongji University: Shanghai, China, 2012.] showed the improved calculation method for cold-formed thin-walled lipped channel sections considering the distortional buckling using the effect width method based on Chinese code GB50018-2002 [18GB50018-2002, Technical code of cold-formed thin-walled steel structure[S], China Architecture and Building Press: Beijing, .], and the buckling stability coefficient of the partially stiffened plates is calculated as follows:
If maximum stress acts on the stiffened edge:
(1) |
(2) |
and the calculated value should be less than the calculated value using formula (1).
If maximum stress acts on the partially stiffened edge:
(3) |
and the calculated value should be less than the calculated value using formula (1).
Where ψ is the factor of non-uniform stress distribution for the partially stiffened element, b is the width of the partially stiffened element, a is the width of lip,t is the thickness of member,I is the lip moment of inertia about the central axis of the lip and the partially stiffened plate, which can be calculated as:
(4) |
λ is the minimum of distortional buckling half-wavelength and length of member. Distortional buckling half-wave length can be obtained as follows:
(5) |
Where h is the height of adjacent stiffened elements, ψ_{w} is the uneven coefficient of the compression stress distribution of the adjacent stiffened element.
There are two factors which affect the material strength, the material strength f_{y} tested using the standard coupons and the disparity coefficient, K_{0 }, considering the difference of the strength value between a standard specimen and the practical engineering material. K_{0 } is equal to 0.94 [19M. Zaiming, C. Xueting, and Y. Deyu, Design reliability analysis of thin-walled structures. Report, Taiyuan University of Technology: Taiyuan, China, 1987.] for cold-formed thin-walled steel structures. So the material strength is equal to f_{y}K_{0 }. Based on the analyzed results of the current steel productions for LQ550 [12L. Yuanqi, S. Zuyan, and W. Lei, "Design reliability analysis of high-strength cold-formed thin-walled steel members with lipped channel sections", J. Build. Struc., vol. 31, no. 11, pp. 36-44.] less than 1.6mm and S350 [13L. Yuanqi, X. Hu, and S. Zuyan, "Design reliability analysis of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with S350 hard-rolled steel sheets", Prog. Steel Build. Struc., vol. 149, no. 6, pp. 21-29.] and S280 [14L. Yuanqi, X. Hu, and S. Zuyan, "Design reliability analysis of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with S280 hard-rolled steel sheets", J. Tongji Uni. (Natural Sci.), vol. 40, no. 8, pp. 1154-1162.] less than 2mm, the statistical analysis results of the different grade steel plates are listed in Table 1. The material strengths are normal distributions when the significance level is less than 5%.
Variation in the geometric characteristics of the structural members includes the dimensional error during fabrication and erection. The fabricated geometric section characteristics of a section should mainly be considered for cold-formed thin-walled steel members. The geometric section characteristics of a section are determined by the geometric shapes, dimension of the cross section, and the situation of external load. The geometric section characteristics are assumed as:
(6) |
Where X_{1},X_{2},X_{n} are random variables affecting the geometric section characteristics.
The standard deviation σ_{F} and variation coefficient V_{F} of F can be obtained using the error transfer theory [20M. Zaiming, "Preliminary analysis of resistance variation of thin-walled steel structures", Indust. Const., vol. 7, pp. 30-35.].
(7) |
(8) |
It is assumed that the uncertainty of geometric section characteristics K_{F} is equal to the ratio of the measured results to the normal values. The mean value μ_{KF} and variation coefficient V_{KF} are calculated using formula (6)-(8).
The statistical results of the geometric characteristics are shown in Table 2 based on the analysis of cold-formed steel lipped channel sections. The uncertainty of geometric characteristics is normal distribution when the significance level is less than 5%.
The uncertainty of the calculation method is because of the error between the theoretical values and the calculated results, which can be determined according to the ratio of the test results to the calculated results using recommend method. The load-carrying capacities of the cold-formed steel lipped channel members shown in references [6L. Yuanqi, W. Shukun, S. Zuyan, and Y. Xingyou, "Experimental study and load-carrying capacity analysis of high-strength cold-formed thin-walled steel channel column under axial compression", J. Build. Struc., vol. 31, no. 11, pp. 17-25.-10S. Yanyong, Experimental investigation on load-carrying capacities of eccentrically-compressed members and self-drilling screw shear connections of cold-formed thin-walled steel structures, M.S. Thesis, Tongji University: Shanghai, China, 2008, 21Z. Yitao, Experimental and design method study on cold-formed channel steel columns with section thickness less than 2 mm under axial compression. M.D. Thesis, Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology: Xi’an, China 2008.], were calculated using the recommend method in this paper as shown in reference [18GB50018-2002, Technical code of cold-formed thin-walled steel structure[S], China Architecture and Building Press: Beijing, .]. The uncertainty of the calculation method is defined as K_{P} = P_{t}/P_{0 }, where P_{t} and P_{0} are the test result and the calculated values using the recommend method, respectively. The statistical results of the calculation method are shown in Table 3. The uncertainty of the calculation method was observed in normal distributions when the significance level was less than 5% using Kolmogorov-Smirnov test method.
The resistance of cold-formed thin-walled steel members [20M. Zaiming, "Preliminary analysis of resistance variation of thin-walled steel structures", Indust. Const., vol. 7, pp. 30-35.] is given as:
(9) |
Where R_{K}, K_{M}, K_{F}, and K_{P} are the characteristics value of the resistance of cold-formed steel members, uncertainty of the material strength of cold-formed steel members, uncertainty of the geometric characteristics of cold-formed steel members, and uncertainty of the calculation method of cold-formed steel members, respectively.
K_{M}, K_{F}, and K_{P} are assumed to be independent of each other. The mean and the standard deviation of the variation coefficient of the resistant of cold-formed thin-walled steel members can be given as formula (10) and (11) using the linearization rule.
(10) |
(11) |
If K_{R} is defined as the ratio value of mean resistant to the characteristics value of the resistant of cold-formed thin-walled steel members, K_{R}= R / R_{K}, the mean value of K_{R} can be obtained as:
(12) |
The resistant R is the product of several variables with normal probability distribution, as shown in formula (10). Because uncertainty of the material strength, of the geometric characteristics and of the calculation method of cold-formed steel members had normal probability distribution, the resistant will have a logarithm normal distribution. The statistical parameters of the resistance model uncertainty of the cold-formed thin-walled steel lipped channel compression members fabricated with LQ550, S350, and S280 cold-formed thin-walled steel plates are listed in Table 4.
Statistical parameters of the uncertainties of different external loads in China can be obtained according to the existing research results [22L. Mingde, H. Dexin, and S. Zhihua, Revision assessment of reliability index of building structures., China Academy of Building Research: Beijing, .], as shown in Table 5.
Two kinds of load combination cases are considered for cold-formed thin-walled steel members based on the Load code for the design of building structures GB50009-2001.
1)The design formula for the combination of dead load, live load, and wind load is given as:
(13) |
2)The design formula for the combination of dead load, live load is given as:
(14) |
Where γ_{G}, γ_{Q}, and γ_{W} are the partial coefficient of the characteristic value of dead load, live load, and wind load, respectively. ψ is the load combination coefficient. S_{Gk}, S_{Lk}, and S_{Wk} are the characteristic value of dead load, live load, and wind load, respectively. R_{K} is the characteristic value of the resistance; γ_{R} is the resistance partial coefficient.
The 24 external load combination cases considered are listed in Table 6. Where ρ_{1} is the ratio values of the sum of the characteristic value of live load and the characteristic value of wind load to the characteristic value of dead load, while ρ_{2} is the ratio values of the characteristic value of wind load to the characteristic value of dead load.
The determination of a suitable target reliability index for cold-formed steel structures can be obtained by the draft of Technical code of cold-formed steel structure [23GB50018, Technical code of cold-formed steel structure (Draft), China Planning Press: Beijing, .] based on Unified standard of reliability design for building structures as shown in Table 7 [24GB50068-2001, Unified standard of reliability design for building structures[S], China Architecture and Building Press: Beijing, .]. Considering the ductility characteristics of cold-formed steel, the target reliability index of Grade A, Grade B, Grade C, and Grade D for LG550 high-strength steel are 3.5, 3.4, 3.3, and 3.2,respectively. The target reliability index of S350 and S280 steel are 3.2.
The resistance partial coefficient is equal to 1.165 for S350, S280, and LG550 compressed members according to the Technical code of cold-formed steel structure (Draft) [23GB50018, Technical code of cold-formed steel structure (Draft), China Planning Press: Beijing, .] and Technical specification for low-rise cold-formed thin-walled steel buildings [11JGJ227-2011, Technical specification for low-rise cold-formed thin-walled steel buildings, China Architecture and Building Press: Beijing, .]. The standard strength and the recommended design strength for S350, S280, and LG550 steel are shown in Table 8.
Based on the resistance uncertainty of cold-formed thin-walled steel members and uncertainties of external loads, the reliability index for S350, S280, and LG550 axially and eccentrically compressed members can be calculated as shown in Tables 9-20 using the improved first-order second-moment method under 24 kinds of external loads combinations.
The reliability index of cold-formed thin-walled steel members as shown in Tables 9-20 shows that the reliability index under office live load is higher than reliability index under residence live load. The S280, S350, LG550 axially- compressed and eccentrically-compressed members can meet the requirements of the target reliability index except grade A, B of LG550 eccentrically-compressed members under a small amount of external load combinations. Considering that the width-to-thickness ratio for grade A, B of LG550 eccentrically-compressed members is beyond the limit of Chinese code, the width-to-thickness ratio of flange was suggested to be less than 60 in cold-formed thin-walled steel structure.
The reliability index of cold-formed thin-walled steel compressive members for LG550, S350, S280 was calculated using the improved first-order second-moment method. The calculated results show that the S280, S350, LG550 axially-compressed and eccentrically-compressed lipped channel members can meet the requirements of the target reliability index when the load-carrying capacities of members are estimated using the effective width method considering distortional buckling, and keeping the resistance partial coefficient equal to 1.165. The width-to-thickness ratio of flange met the requirement of Chinese cold-formed steel code. The distortional buckling strength of lipped channel steel members in engineering structures can be calculated using the proposed method in this paper when the width-to-thickness ratio of flange meets the requirement of Chinese cold-formed steel code.
Not applicable.
The author declare no conflict of interest, financial or otherwise.
The author gratefully acknowledges the financial support provided by the Department of Science and Technology Natural Science Foundation Projects of Jiangxi Province in China (No: 20151BAB206055), National Natural Science Foundation Projects of China (No: 51308277), China Postdoctoral Science Foundation funded project (No: 2016M590382), and Science and Technology Innovation Team Foundation Projects of Jiangxi Province in China (No: 20171BCB19001).
[1] | B.W. Schafer, "Local, distortional, and Euler buckling of thin-walled columns", J. Struc. Eng., vol. 128, no. 3, pp. 289-299. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9445(2002)128:3(289)] |
[2] | AISI S100-2007, North American Standard for Seismic Design of Cold-formed Steel Structural Systems, Washington, D.C, . |
[3] | G.J. Hancock, "Design for distortional buckling of flexural members", Thin-walled Struc., vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 3-12. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0263-8231(96)00020-1] |
[4] | B.W.T.Pekoz Schafer, and T. Pekoz, "Laterally braced cold-formed steel flexural members with edge stiffened flanges", J. Struct. Eng., vol. 125, no. 2, pp. 118-127. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9445(1999)125:2(118)] |
[5] | Y.B. Kwon, B.S. Kim, and G.J. Hancock, "Compression tests of high strength cold-formed steel channels with buckling interaction", J. Construct. Steel Res., vol. 65, no. 2, pp. 278-289. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jcsr.2008.07.005] |
[6] | L. Yuanqi, W. Shukun, S. Zuyan, and Y. Xingyou, "Experimental study and load-carrying capacity analysis of high-strength cold-formed thin-walled steel channel column under axial compression", J. Build. Struc., vol. 31, no. 11, pp. 17-25. |
[7] | L. Yuanqi, L. Xiang, S. Zuyan, and Y. Xingyou, "Experimental study and load-carrying capacity analysis of eccentrically-compressed high-strength cold-formed thin-walled steel channel column", J. Build. Struc., vol. 31, no. 11, pp. 26-35. |
[8] | S. Zuyan, L. Yuanqi, and W. Shudong, Experimental research on load-carrying capacities of cold-formed super thin-walled axiallycompressed members with channel section, Report, Tongji University, Shanghai Beststeel Structure Building Co., Ltd.: Shanghai, China 2010 |
[9] | S. Zuyan, L. Yuanqi, and W. Shudong, Experimental research on load-carrying capacities of cold-formed super thin-walled eccentrically-compressed members with channel section, Report, Tongji University, Shanghai Beststeel Structure Building Co., Ltd.: Shanghai, China, 2010. |
[10] | S. Yanyong, Experimental investigation on load-carrying capacities of eccentrically-compressed members and self-drilling screw shear connections of cold-formed thin-walled steel structures, M.S. Thesis, Tongji University: Shanghai, China, 2008 |
[11] | JGJ227-2011, Technical specification for low-rise cold-formed thin-walled steel buildings, China Architecture and Building Press: Beijing, . |
[12] | L. Yuanqi, S. Zuyan, and W. Lei, "Design reliability analysis of high-strength cold-formed thin-walled steel members with lipped channel sections", J. Build. Struc., vol. 31, no. 11, pp. 36-44. |
[13] | L. Yuanqi, X. Hu, and S. Zuyan, "Design reliability analysis of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with S350 hard-rolled steel sheets", Prog. Steel Build. Struc., vol. 149, no. 6, pp. 21-29. |
[14] | L. Yuanqi, X. Hu, and S. Zuyan, "Design reliability analysis of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with S280 hard-rolled steel sheets", J. Tongji Uni. (Natural Sci.), vol. 40, no. 8, pp. 1154-1162. |
[15] | Y. Xingyou, L. Yuanqi, and S. Zuyan, "Nonlinear distortional-buckling strength estimation of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with lipped channel section", J. Cent. South Uni. (Sci. and Tech.), vol. 46, no. 8, pp. 3067-3074. |
[16] | Y. Xingyou, and L. Yuanqi, "Distortional buckling strength of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with lipped channel section", Eng. Mech., vol. 319, no. 9, pp. 174-181. |
[17] | Y. Xingyou, Distortional buckling behavior and design method of cold-formed thin-walled steel members with opening section, Report, Tongji University: Shanghai, China, 2012. |
[18] | GB50018-2002, Technical code of cold-formed thin-walled steel structure[S], China Architecture and Building Press: Beijing, . |
[19] | M. Zaiming, C. Xueting, and Y. Deyu, Design reliability analysis of thin-walled structures. Report, Taiyuan University of Technology: Taiyuan, China, 1987. |
[20] | M. Zaiming, "Preliminary analysis of resistance variation of thin-walled steel structures", Indust. Const., vol. 7, pp. 30-35. |
[21] | Z. Yitao, Experimental and design method study on cold-formed channel steel columns with section thickness less than 2 mm under axial compression. M.D. Thesis, Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology: Xi’an, China 2008. |
[22] | L. Mingde, H. Dexin, and S. Zhihua, Revision assessment of reliability index of building structures., China Academy of Building Research: Beijing, . |
[23] | GB50018, Technical code of cold-formed steel structure (Draft), China Planning Press: Beijing, . |
[24] | GB50068-2001, Unified standard of reliability design for building structures[S], China Architecture and Building Press: Beijing, . |