Table 2: Clinical Studies with 3D Analysis of Wear Rate with 1st Generation HXLPE

Study Design HXLPE Head Follow-Up Conclusions
Bragdon et al.J Arthrop 2007(EFORT ‘09) Non-consecutive, non-randomized30 hips Longevity 100 kGy, remelted 28mmCrCo (16 hips)vs36mmCrCo(14 hips) 3 yearsEFORT 09:7-10yr No diff 3D between28 and 36mm
Röhrl et al.Acta Orthop 2007 Retrospective, comparative56 hips/53 Crossfire105 KGy, annealed 28 mm CrCo XLPE 6 yr, Std 5 yr No wear rate progression at 6yr re oxidation
Digas et al.Acta Orthop 2007 (cem) Prospective, randomized56 hips Durasul95 kGy, remelted 28 mm CrCo 5 years 0.001 vs0.06mm/yr (3D) (98% decrease)
Digas et al.Acta Orthop 2007 (hybr) Prospective, randomized contralat control32 hips/32 Longevity100 KGy, remelted 28 mm CrCo 5 years 0.00 vs0.057mm/yr(3D)(99-100% decrease)
Glyn-Jones et al.J Arthrop 2008 Prospective, doub-blind, rand, controlled26 hips/25 Longevity100 KGy, remelted 28 mm CrCo 2 years 0.06 mm/yr vs0.10 (3D)(40% decrease)