Table 1: Studies of Wear Rates of Alumina-on-Polyethylene Bearing Total Hip Arthroplasty

Study No. of Hips Follow-Up Duration (Year) Acetabular Bearing Diameter (mm) Linear Wear Rates (mm/Year) Range Linear WearRates Wear Measurement
Zichner et al. [16] 5 UHMWPE 0.1-0.2 Buchhorn
Sugano et al. [29] 57 11.1 UHMWPE 28 0.10 0-0.31 Computerized
Wroblewski et al. [21] 19 6.4 XLP 22.225 0.06 0.024-0.32 Collins
Livingston et al. [22] 7 14-16 Hylamer 28 0.33 Livermoore
Sychterz et al. [23] 9 10-19 UHMWPE 32 0.16 Computerized
Sychterz et al. [18] 81 7 UHMWPE 32 0.09 Computerized
Oonish et al. [5] 12 100Mrad PE 28 0.05 SD 0.03 Livermoore
111 UHMWPE 28 0.1 SD 0.007 Livermoore
Hasegawa et al. [24] 44 13 UHMWPE 28 0.1 Livermoore
Haraguchi et al. [20] 101 14 UHMWPE 28 0.15 0.04-.034 Computerized (Sugano)
Urban et al. [12] 18 18.2 UHMWPE 32 0.034 0.00016-0.077 Livermoore
Tanaka et al. [30] 67 13.6 UHMWPE 28 0.036-0.365 Computerized
41 10.8 UHMWPE 26 0.005-0.199 (Sychterz)
48 9.2 UHMWPE 22 0.007-0.342
Hernigou and Bahrami [13] 56 10.8 UHMWPE 32 0.071 0.041-0.101 Magnifier (Devane)
Kim et al. [15] 101 9.2 UHMWPE 28 0.07 0.01-0.27 Livermoore
Kim et al. [14] 67 7 UHMWPE 28 0.07 0.01-0.23 Dorr and Wan
Wroblewski et al. [25] 11 17 XLP 22.225 0.019 0-0.026 Collins
Liang et al. [26] 46 6.7 UHMWPE 22 0.078 0.02-0.27 Computerized (Sychterz)
Kim et al. [27] 30 11.3 UHMWPE 28 0.1 0.09-0.12 Computerized
Lewis et al. [28] 26 8.1 UHMWPE 28 0.11 Dorr and Wan
Kim et al. [44] 100 5.6 HXLPE 28 0.06 0-0.08 Computerized